Funding Feeds Fads

A modern brain filled with Latin

This article must be reliable, because it contains a picture of a brain.

If there weren’t so much money in education, we would probably be better off.

The only really essential thing to spend money on is good teachers. And good teachers are more than capable of training other teachers. But when billions of government cash is washing around, there is a strong temptation to spend it on a well-known guru who will initiate staff into the dark arts of the latest trendy fad. They’ve published a book and it’s sold millions, so they must know what they’re talking about, right? They’ve even been on telly! The headmaster will be able to pose for a photo which will appear in the local newspaper, and everyone will be wowed by how up to date the school is.

In order to justify their large fees, gurus need to make a strong sales pitch, and they need to offer something unique. This is how myths are perpetuated. It just wouldn’t be good enough to talk in the cautious, measured, humble language of real science. Pseudoscience always makes big claims. If the lie is big enough then plenty will believe in it. Throw some spurious statistics about and use words like ‘brain’ and ‘neuro[insert suffix]’ a lot, then offer the surefire solution to all these scientific complexities.

Don’t tell me I’m fighting a straw man. ‘Brain training’ is an international industry worth billions of dollars, when the only proven benefits to the brain are to be had from regular exercise, a balanced diet, sufficient rest, and yes, using your brain. Thinking about stuff.

More money led to ever greater spending on worthless nonsense in the Labour years. How can education leaders be prevented from spending taxpayer’s money on worthless fads? Academies have more freedom to waste money, not less.

The answer lies in the battle of ideas, the battleground to which Andrew Old refers in the title of his blog. That is the fight which will raise standards, far more than funding increases or governance changes.

(Image from Wikimedia)


3 thoughts on “Funding Feeds Fads

  1. Well said
    BLP has a picture of a brain too!
    I have contacted Guy Claxton’s Building Learning Power and they are yet to reply (at all) with evidence of whether their product actually works
    Andrew Old wrote an excellent post on this which gave me hope at a difficult time. Sadly my school still believes in it. Google ‘snake oil’
    I wish there were more posts like these including traditionalteacher’s (thanks). The truth has to come out one day.


  2. I’m sure you are familiar with what has happened in Canada. We now have 2 provinces who have adopted 21st century learning curricula and we are heading down a very scary wormhole. As said, all the more justification for ed consultants to spend big budgets. One of the designers of this new curricula was on the radio the other day. She said although they had no idea if it would work, and have no support systems in place for either students or teachers, and not sure if government would be spending money on teacher resources. she hoped it would work. Soooo….let’s just throw a kid into the middle of a lake and say, “JUST SWIM!” and hope he/she can. This will have devastating consequences for our kids. I hope more attention will be brought to this issue.


Thoughtful and reasonable discussion is always welcome.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s